What's wrong with American Idol ?

They are supposed to be singing Rock's finest song and yet the best performance from the judges point of view came from David Archuleta.

You call Stand by Me and Love Me Tender a Rock and Roll song, you gotta be kidding me.

David Cook is the only Idol that personifies their motif for Rock and Roll song with his rockin performance.

Are the Idols producer being biased to David Archuleta? It was supposed to be rock and roll week, but what have we seen? We've seen and heard pop songs on a Rock and Roll week.

About Jason Castro, he did tried to Rock bu unfortunately he should drink a lot of memory enhancer so as not to forget the lyrics next time, that is if just in case he gets lucky and manage to stay with the show.

When you mean Rock and Roll, you should mean it. David Cook showed the way how to rocks.