American Idol Most Brilliant Performance to date

The Boys stood out today in these week’s American Idol, where the show is all about Mariah Carey’s songs.

David Archuleta started the show with a strong rendition of Miracle, a duet by Mariah Carey and Whitney Houston. The judges loved him so much that Simon Cowell said that David Archuleta is the one to beat tonight.

Carly Smithson, who seems to be getting beautiful and beautiful every week, followed up with Without You. Followed by Sasyha Mercado with an unpopular song by Mariah Carey.

Brooke White and Kristy Lee Cook’s performance are so damn poor, that I even think that Kristy Lee Cook is about to leave the show. This week might just be it.

The Most Brilliant Performance to date according to Randy Jackson was by no other than Mr. It, David Cook, and the complete package according to Paula Abdul. She even said that his rendition of Always be my baby,could be a movie soundtrack. Randy also said that he could start making a hit record now. Simon also applauded David Cook’s performance. David Cook was all tears after the judges’ raves about him.

Jason Castro ended the show with a cool song, more of a beach song according to Randy Jackson. But it was also a great cover for Mariah’s songs.

Who would you vote off ?

We've seen them perform and now it's time for us to judge them. Who would you vote out ?

The Final 12 sung their Lennon-McCartney Songs and some of them are just not great.

Syesha Mercado was electrifying in the opening.As usual David Cook rocks the house with his rendition of Eleonor Rigby. Chikezie was also amazing with his performance.Rockers Carly Smithson and Amanda Overmyer rocks the house.

Kristy Lee Cook did a country style Eight Days a Week and Simon wasn't impressed, although I'm impressed with her beauty. It was a soulful performance for Brooke White, Jason Castro and Michael Johns.

Now that leaves me to my weakest three, Ramiele Malubay, David Hernandez and David Archuleta. David Archuleta even forgot some of his lyrics.

My choice to leave is David Hernandez. His version of I Saw Her Standing There was awful, dreadful and forgettable.

How about you, who do yout hink should go ?