America got it wrong once again

America had done it again; they committed the mistake twice this season. First it was the ouster of Michael Johns and now it was Carly Smithson’s turn to leave the show American Idol.

Carly Smithson is the best performer last night with her rendition of Jesus Christ Superstar.

Brooke White was the one who was supposed to leave the show; Americans just got it all wrong once again. Her performance was so weak and her voice was trembling when she was performing. Besides she committed the biggest blunder ever in American Idol. Forgetting the lyrics and starting over again is forgettable.

Carly was robbed of her place; she should still be staying in the show.

I was also surprised that Brooke White was not even in the bottom two; instead Carly shares the spot with Syesha Mercado. Syesha Mercado also had a big night last night.

Maybe next week, Brooke White will leave the show or yet again another shocker will happen in the show.

Carly Smithson's version of Jesus Christ Superstar

Carly Smithson's Big Night

Brooke White committed the most outrageous blunder in the American Idol. She forgot the lyrics that she had to start from the beginning. Andrew Lloyd Webber was all praised about Brooke, but lo and behold Brooke just stopped and said sorry. Must have been mental block or maybe the spotlight is just too bright for her, after her song, her face was all gloomy and her eyes were teary. I just think that she will be out this week.

Syesha Mercado was so hot and sexy during her presentation. Randy was right saying that it was her most brilliant performance. Jason Castro was kinda nervous while performing, the song just didn’t fit in his category. If Brooke just didn’t get into trouble I would have vote him out.

David Archuleta and David Cook continues to sizzle with their awesome show of brilliance during their performance.

But the night belongs to Carly Smithson who simply just brings down the house with her rockin powerful performance to date with her very own rendition of Jesus Christ Superstar. Her performance simply suits her very strong personality. Andrew Lloyd Webber just got the right idea of changing her song from All I ask of you to Jesus Christ Superstar. Good thing Carly listened to Mr. Andrew Lloyd Webber and her performance bolster her chances of making it to the top three.

American Idol Most Brilliant Performance to date

The Boys stood out today in these week’s American Idol, where the show is all about Mariah Carey’s songs.

David Archuleta started the show with a strong rendition of Miracle, a duet by Mariah Carey and Whitney Houston. The judges loved him so much that Simon Cowell said that David Archuleta is the one to beat tonight.

Carly Smithson, who seems to be getting beautiful and beautiful every week, followed up with Without You. Followed by Sasyha Mercado with an unpopular song by Mariah Carey.

Brooke White and Kristy Lee Cook’s performance are so damn poor, that I even think that Kristy Lee Cook is about to leave the show. This week might just be it.

The Most Brilliant Performance to date according to Randy Jackson was by no other than Mr. It, David Cook, and the complete package according to Paula Abdul. She even said that his rendition of Always be my baby,could be a movie soundtrack. Randy also said that he could start making a hit record now. Simon also applauded David Cook’s performance. David Cook was all tears after the judges’ raves about him.

Jason Castro ended the show with a cool song, more of a beach song according to Randy Jackson. But it was also a great cover for Mariah’s songs.

American Idol most Inspirational performance

In this week's American Idol whereas the theme is inspirational, there is one performance that I think stood out from among the rest of the Top 8.

It was Jason Castro singing Somewhere over the rainbow. It was the version done by Israel Kamakwiwo'ole that he sings instead of the version by Judy Garland. It was just so inspiring, the audience were caught in awe and was silent as if paying attention to every word that's coming out of Jason Castro's mouth.

Simon Cowell calls it fantastic. Other Idol finalist failed to impress the judge with David Cook, Michael John and Carly Smithson receiving the most blows from the judges.

Watch the video above to see what I am talking about.